Month: August 2025

“City of the Dead” by Sara Gran

Gran’s highly unusual protagonist, the private eye Claire DeWitt, knows an awful lot. She is wise beyond her years and more daring than most of fiction’s male detectives, often to the point of being reckless. She is confident that no case will remain open under her watch, with the exception of the disappearance of her teenage best friend Tracy, a tragic theme that repeats within the DeWitt series of novels.

Also reiterated in the series is Claire’s history as apprentice to the late detective Constance Darling (they lived and worked together in New Orleans, a fact that prompted Claire to return there and take on a case). We are also treated, as in Gran’s other “Claire” novels, to excerpts and examples from French author Jaques Sillete’s counter-intuitive Zen-like book on the art of solving a crime.

Using his teaching points, Claire shows how she can find clues in unexpected ways. She has an uncanny ability to relate to the people of New Orleans, from the Garden District privileged to the deep-ward street level. She has a tough outlaw side of her own. Knowing what pain and bad luck can be, she is able to meet anyone down and out on equal grounds and interact via exchanges of frankness and respect. There’s some remarkable writing depicting these interactions. She has an edge in how to get information, a desirable trait for any private detective.

Her rapport is especially rare when she engages with some pistol-toting black youths with whom the ravages and injustices of hurricane Katrina are still fresh and raw. In the world of forty-ounce malt-liquor beers, uppers, lies, and violence, she seeks and manages to find accomplices and allies, not enemies.

More importantly, she has heart. Lots of it, and we feel it.

“Infinite Blacktop” by Sara Gran

The book consists of three narratives, each at a different place and time, each with their own line of action. There are common elements defining the background, life and career of Claire DeWitt, the private eye who by her own cocky admission no one ever defeats. Having read one of the other DeWitt novels, I already knew about her mentorship under Constance Darling and her deep study in the cult book Detection written by Jacques Sillete. The Sillete book is fictitious, but she makes it so intriguing we wish it was out there on Amazon.

I like how Gran writes. Informally, brash, yet with skill and measure. Her character’s search in these stories is not so much for the whodunnit aspects, but to find retribution and meaning in, or confirmation of, what is right. This is not a superficial exploration she makes. It is heart-rendering, totally committed, down to the blood and bones level. We all miss Tracy and feel Claire’s pain for her. When Claire suffers, we do. When she makes mistakes and still brags, we cringe. When she gets cornered and in trouble (repeatedly) we root for her to get away. When she wins and finds respite and understanding, we do too.

If I go back for a second read one day, I would thumb through the pages and read each part separately. My hat’s off to Sara Gran, who has shown the bigshot book guys what she can do, and has now carved a way to run her own publishing company.

“Generation Loss” by Elizabeth Hand

I went shopping earlier this year for mystery novels narrated from the perspective of a modern, female character. I read in the NYT about this Elizabeth Hand book, which won a notable award, and seemed a likely starter for what I was looking for. I have been long accustomed to the hardboiled accounts from male-centric crime and detective novels by old craftsmen like Chandler, Hammett, MacDonald; and newer ones like Lindsey, Markson, and James Lee Burke, etc. In the aughts, I read two of those amazingly engaging “Girl With ___” novels by Stieg Larsson. When he died, I quit reading mysteries altogether and went back to my usual fare of snobby supposedly literary novels, of which half were remarkable and the other half mostly NYC publisher hype. No wonder I retreated to older tried and true novels.

In this novel, Hand’s heroine is Cass Neary. Cass is not a detective but is reckless and ends up being one. Like Larsson’s first “Tattoo” novel, we follow Neary and root for her. The pages fly by. The rugged coastal Maine setting and cast of characters are intriguing. We are there and feel it. It’s, as they say in CW 101, atmospheric. Of course it doesn’t last, this lyrical writing, because the sellers of mystery/crime books demand storylines explode with ghastly appeal to the most jaded of book readers.

Cass wanders off with the curiosity of a typical Gothic heroine and finds out more than she bargained for, reaching shore on the bad guy’s property on an even more remote island than the bleak, subsistance-level one she had been staying on. Oddly, in a bit of dubious editing, the bad guy’s place is somehow like a self-sufficient Four Seasons Resort, complete with a Chamber of Horrors. It reminded me that Larsson’s first book went off the tracks in a similar way, with a far-fetched B&D dungeon and torture basement making us erase all our nicer memories of fast-lane life in cool Sweden.

Cass Neary is much like Claire DeWitt in Sara Gran’s series (to be posted soon) that also features a lovable punk, down & out, beer-swilling, pill-taking tough-ass grrrl renunciant who gets knocked around to hell and back but still keeps going in order to find the truth and prove a point.

The ghost and soul of the crime/detective genre’s most unforgettable woman character — Lisbeth Salander — remains as Influencer.

.

.